: Obsessed with Christmas, Dusty Marlow attempts to restore the town's missing "Christmas spirit" to ensure a visit from Santa Claus. This leads him to a confrontation with a Mall Santa, whom he literally crushes while demanding a "Chuggy Chuggy Choo Choo" toy he never received as a child.
The episode follows two main narrative threads that converge at the Paradise Police Department: [S1E10] Christmas in Paradise
: While Fitz remains in a coma, Kevin Crawford works tirelessly to uncover the traitor within the department who killed Terry Two-Toes. The Big Reveal: Who is the Kingpin? : Obsessed with Christmas, Dusty Marlow attempts to
In a major cliffhanger ending, it is revealed that (Gerald Fitzgerald) is the mastermind behind the Argyle Meth corporation. He has been faking his coma and was the one responsible for the murder of Terry Two-Toes, effectively setting himself up as the primary antagonist for the following season. Key Episode Highlights The Big Reveal: Who is the Kingpin
: Dusty’s holiday spirit is shattered when the Mall Santa reveals he is actually a meth distributor.
The episode features the series' core voice cast and was written by the show’s creators. Voice Actor David Herman Chief Randall Crawford Gina Jabowski Sarah Chalke Dusty Marlow Dana Snyder Fitz / Kingpin Cedric Yarbrough Bullet Kyle Kinane
: In a bizarre subplot, Dusty is mistaken for a woman and briefly imprisoned in a women’s penitentiary despite his protests.